In an attempt to revert time, Mordecai and Rigby travelled in time with a time-machine to prevent Past Mordecai from eating smelly foods. However, they tried to force Past Mordecai into use a mouth wash, but when Mordecai's plan goes wrong, Past Mordecai takes the time machine from his hands and goes into the future to kiss Margaret.
Rigby had another time-machine and they go after Past Mordecai to prevent him, when travelling in time. Mordecai tricks Past Mordecai so that he can keep him from kissing Margaret. When they finally reach Past Mordecai, Rigby uses one of the time-machines to take Past Mordecai to the future again.
Then, Mordecai breaks the first time-machine in the past and Rigby breaks the second time-machine in the future.
Past Mordecai's personality is almost identical to his good counterpart, however, Past Mordecai is more evil and arrogant, he will do nearly anything to kiss Margaret... even defeat, humiliate or even kill his good counterpart.
- He is one of the many evil versions of the characters, like Iacedrom & Ygbir, Ybgir, Guardian of Secrets, Hologram 9000, Stress and Future Mordecai & Rigby.
- Unlike the other evil versions, Past Mordecai is identical to his good version.
- However, he has pure white feathers in his chest, unlike Mordecai in some episodes.