Mike was one of the most popular students at Powell. He was a straight A student, a varsity athlete, and the president of the local Meals on Wheels club, as well as having a reputation as a womanizer. During his time at college, he raped at least ten women, usually by taking them on a date, charming them with a paper rose, then forcing himself on them. Only two women reported him. Regie Kunze reported him to the Dean, who did nothing. Tessie Bartram went to the police, but no charges were laid. He marked his victims in his yearbook with a drawing of a rose.
He was selected to be Valedictorian, despite the Dean knowing about at least one of the rapes. In his speech, he quoted Martin Luther King- "our lives begin to end the day we become silent about the things that matter".
A number of Mike's victims eventually made contact with each other, writing on the wall of a women's washroom, including Tessie, Regie, Sheana, Melinda Levy, and Karin Hensley. For Sheana, who had attempted to tell Jason McNulty her father, only to be blamed for it herself, the ordeal proved too much, and she committed suicide. The other four women eventually conspired to stop him together.
Shortly after graduation, Mike was confronted on the quad by Tessie, Melinda, Karin, and Regie. Mike initially dismissed their accusations and started to leave until Tessie pulled out a gun she'd been given by a sympathetic policewoman, Maggie Lafferty. Frightening Mike to the point of wetting his pants, they forced him at gunpoint to admit that he had raped them. Regie urged Tessie to kill Mike, but she refused, declaring that she didn't want to become him. Tessie and the others then walked away, tossing the gun in a garbage can.
After the women had left, Mike, completely unrepentant, laughed about their reaction as he got up. He then spotted Tessie's twelve year-old brother, Jimmy Bartram, who had overheard his sister's rape and followed her to the quad, picking up the gun from the garbage can. Jimmy told Mike he knew what Mike had done to his sister, that she had said no. Mike, deciding Jimmy wasn't capable of shooting him, goaded Jimmy, saying his sister was "one hell of a lay." With that, Jimmy pointed the gun at Mike shot him. He then ran, discarding the gun three blocks away. A security guard found Mike's body the next morning.
Mike's murder was fully investigated, but police were unable to find his killer.
In 2007, to commemorate the 25th anniversary of his death, Powell University planned a special event. In response, a disgusted Reggie vandalized Mike's grave with the word 'Rapist'. This led to the Philadelphia Homicide Squad re-investigating Mike's death. The revelation that Mike had raped girls gave detectives a new approach in the investigation.
Several of Mike's victims, including Tessie, Regie, Karin, and Melinda, were interviewed with suspicion passing between them, until the investigation led to Jimmy, now a lawyer. A sympathetic detective Lilly Rush and Scotty Valens chose to interpret it as a self-defense shooting however, and Jimmy was not charged.
- Mike's family are not mentioned in the episode, however, given that he was buried in Philadelphia it is likely that he had family in the area.
- The date of Mike's death is unclear. Mike was explicitly said to have been killed the night of graduation, with the caption at the beginning of the episode giving the date as May 18, however the headstone at Mike's grave gives the date of his death at May 29.