Atop a scaffolding, Kyoko is idly watching Elsa's barrier while eating an ice cream bar. Homura appears silently behind her, and asks her if she is going to allow Sayaka to take her kill. Kyoko at first brushes this off, telling Homura that since it's an actual witch and will drop a Grief Seed, that it isn't a waste like before. However, she notices strange behavior in the barrier, then curses, muttering that Sayaka is botching the fight. The scene switches to Sayaka and Madoka within the barrier; Elsa is seated in a prayerlike position on top of a long arm holding a monstrance. Sayaka is then seen charging forth at Elsa Maria, which defends itself with snakelike animals and gnarled branches and vines. It fends off Sayaka, injuring her, and Kyoko soon comes to her rescue. Kyoko is about to attack the witch when Sayaka gets up and tells her to stay out of it. Sayaka again rushes forward, this time cutting past the vines, and reaches the witch. She slashes at the witch repeatedly, and begins to laugh insanely while blood splatters on her face.
"He (Kyubey) was right. If I don't want it to, it doesn't hurt at all," are Sayaka's closing lines before she bisects the witch, referring to Kyubey's comment in the beginning of the episode about purposely numbing pain. The scene fades to black, and Madoka's voice is heard pleading, "Stop. Please stop."
"The witch of shadow with a self-righteous nature. She continually prays for all of creation and drags all life equally into her shadow without breaking her posture. One hoping to defeat her must know the blackest anguish."
Symbolism of the witch
Due to this description, Elsa Maria may symbolize religious hypocrisy. Her symbolism includes Christian crosses, and the ground in her barrier that forms a large arm holding either a torch or a monstrance. Elsa Maria appears to be praying before this object when Sayaka engages her.
Elsa Maria's nature as the Witch of Shadow is ironic since religion is usually associated to holy light and enlightment.
Furthermore, Elsa Maria's powers seem to be based on the Garden of Eden. She fights with fanged snake-like minions and tree branches that extend from her body, probably standing in for the famous serpent that tempts Eve, and the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil itself on which grew the forbidden fruit.
Some fans have speculated that she may be Kyoko Sakura's sister Momo.