Chet was the team captain of his high school football team, and one of the many boyfriends whom Susan LeGrow dated only to later cheat on with another.
On the night of the school prom, Chet found Susan cheating on him with another man, driving Chet insane. He clubbed the man to death and strangled Susan to death with his school tie, before burying her body under the 20-yard line of the school football field.
Chet was eventually caught after Susan's buried body was found two weeks later. He was arrested and sentenced to death, his last words being "the bitch broke my heart, so I broke her neck." .